Power BI vs Excel: When to switch from spreadsheets to interactive dashboards?
Excel has been the standard tool for reporting in companies for decades. From simple tables to complex formulas and pivot tables, Excel is powerful, flexible, and widespread. However, many organizations run into the boundaries of spreadsheets as their data volumes, reporting needs, or teams grow. Enter Power BI: a modern business intelligence tool from Microsoft that enables real-time dashboards, automatic data processing and powerful visualizations.
In this article, we compare Power BI and Excel in the context of KPI reporting. What are the strengths of each platform, when is Excel sufficient and when is it worthwhile to switch to Power BI?
Ease of use and learning curve
Excel has a low entry threshold. Anyone who works with numbers has opened an Excel file at least once. The interface is recognisable, the functions are intuitive, and countless tutorials are available. Excel is often more than sufficient for basic reporting.
Power BI requires a little more practice, especially for those who have no experience with data modeling or DAX formulas. The structure of a report takes place in several steps: retrieving data, modeling, drawing up calculations, visualizing. Nevertheless, the learning curve is achievable, especially for users who are already familiar with Excel or other Microsoft tools.
Conclusion: Excel can be deployed more quickly. Power BI initially requires a little more time, but pays off in case of larger reporting needs.
Visualizations and dashboards
Power BI is built around visual data analysis. The tool offers an extensive library of visuals: columns, graphs, gauges, funnels, matrices, and more. Each element is interactive: if you click on a segment, the rest of the dashboard automatically filters along. You can easily compare KPIs over time, by region or product group.
Excel also offers graphs, but the options are more limited and less intuitive. Interactive dashboards in Excel often require a lot of work, formulas, and VBA scripts. Plus, they're less scalable and harder to maintain.
Conclusion: for visual KPI reporting, Power BI is the clear winner.
Automation and data renewal
Power BI supports automatic data refresh via direct links to data sources (SQL, Excel, SharePoint, cloud tools...). Reports are updated automatically at predefined times. This eliminates manual work and increases the reliability of the numbers.
Excel can retrieve data via Power Query or ODBC links, but requires more manual intervention. In addition, formulas can easily be overwritten, which leads to errors.
Conclusion: Power BI is much stronger in automation and real-time updates. Excel is more sensitive to manual errors.
Data Modeling and Computing Power
Power BI is designed to process large data sets. With DAX formulas, you can perform complex calculations, including time intelligence (YTD, YoY, MTD). You can link different tables via relationships, without the need for vlookup formulas or index-match combinations.
Excel works mainly with flat tables. When you want to combine multiple tables or make dynamic calculations over time periods, things get complicated and prone to errors.
Conclusion: Power BI is better suited to multi-dimensional data models and complex calculations.
Collaboration and version control
Power BI-reports are shared via the cloud (Power BI Service). Users are always working with the latest version of the report. With Row-Level Security (RLS), you can decide who can see what data, without having to create separate files. Everyone works in the same reporting environment.
Excelfiles are often forwarded by mail or stored in a shared folder. Version control is becoming a challenge: “definitief_v3_FINAL_FINAL.xlsx” is no exception. Collaborating with multiple people at the same time is possible via OneDrive, but remains less streamlined.
Conclusion: Power BI offers better collaboration, central distribution, and version control.
Cost structure and licensing
Excel is part of the Microsoft 365 package, which many companies are already using anyway. No additional licenses are required for basic use. This makes Excel budget-friendly for small teams or simple reports.
Power BI Desktop is free, but publishing and sharing reports via Power BI Service requires a Pro license. For larger organizations, there is Power BI Premium, with more capacity and advanced capabilities.
Conclusion: Excel is cheaper for individual use. Power BI offers more value for teams and scaling up, at a limited cost.
Typical Excel use cases
- You work with small datasets (<50,000 rows)
- You build ad-hoc reports or do rapid analyses
- You don't need collaboration or central distribution
- Your KPIs change regularly and require flexibility
- You don't (yet) have IT support or Power BI licenses
Typical Power BI use cases
- You work with multiple data sources or large datasets
- You want one central source of truth for your KPIs
- You're looking for automatic updates and visual insights
- You have a data-driven team with multiple users
- You want to easily share reports with colleagues or customers
When to switch?
Moving from Excel to Power BI is rarely all-or-nothing. Many organizations start with Excel for data exploration, but build their structural KPI dashboard in Power BI. It is perfectly possible to let Power BI start from existing Excel files or models.
Signs that you're ready to make the switch:
- You copy or paste data into Excel every month
- You work with multiple files for different departments
- Your KPIs are error-prone or difficult to reproduce
- You no longer have a clear overview of performance
- Your colleagues interpret reports in different ways
Combining Power BI and Excel?
You don't have to choose. Power BI and Excel complement each other perfectly. For example, you can:
- Using Power BI for dashboards
- Using Excel for Ad Hoc Analysis and Exports
- Importing Excel data into Power BI
- Exporting Power BI reports to Excel for offline use
Other Power BI alternatives?
Be sure to also look at other alternatives that are sometimes better suited to your needs. The InsightData Apps provide out-of-the-box business intelligence for all your business data.
Common mistakes when switching
- Thinking that Power BI is completely replacing Excel
- No time provided for training and set-up
- Copy reports without structure or data model
- Do not set KPI definitions for publication
- Build reports without user feedback or iteration
Conclusion: choose consciously, scale smartly
Excel is a great tool for quick reporting and individual analysis. But if your organization grows, wants to monitor more KPIs, or uses multiple data sources, Power BI is a possible next step.
Start small, for example with a Power BI dashboard based on your existing Excel numbers. Test the benefits of automation, interactive filtering, and collaboration. You will notice that it not only works faster, but also looks more professional and creates more support.
Continue reading?
See how Power BI compares to the pre-configured InsightData apps on Qlik Sense.
Discover the key differences between Power BI and Qlik Sense in analytics power and flexibility.
Find out if Qlik Sense or Tableau is a better fit for your data strategy.
Compare Power BI to Looker in terms of cloud functionality, governance, and scalability.
The complete guide to effective KPI dashboards