Qlik Sense vs Tableau: Which BI tool is best for your organization?
Tableau and Qlik Sense are among the absolute top of self-service business intelligence tools. Both offer powerful features for data visualization, analysis, and dashboarding. But there are big differences in how they work, what they make possible, and what type of organization they're best suited to. In this article, we compare both platforms thoroughly so that you can make the right choice based on your needs, team and technical context.
User experience and interface
Tableau is known for its user-friendly drag and drop interface. Building graphs is intuitive, with instant feedback and preview as you build. For non-technical users, Tableau is highly accessible.
Qlik Sense works on the basis of an associative data model, allowing users to easily discover connections between different data points. The interface is sleek but less visually intuitive than Tableau. However, it allows you to filter and explore very flexibly, even without prior knowledge of SQL.
Conclusion: Tableau is a little more user-friendly for beginners. Qlik Sense is more powerful for those who want to explore without fixed dashboards.
Data analysis and flexibility
Qlik Sense excels in explorative analysis. Thanks to the associative model, you can navigate through your data in any direction. No predefined drill down structures: you can click on any element and get new insights automatically. This makes Qlik ideal for root cause analysis and ad hoc queries.
Tableau offers strong analysis tools, but works more hierarchically. Filters and parameters must be set in advance. This makes Tableau less suitable for free data exploration, but stronger in storytelling via dashboards.
Conclusion: For analysis with a lot of unstructured questions, Qlik is stronger. For dashboards with preset reports, Tableau is ideal.
Data Modeling and Scripting
Qlik Sense uses your own script editor where you define your data model. You can set logic, transformations, and joins yourself, which provides a lot of flexibility. Ideal for complex data models or data preparation within the tool itself.
Tableau relies on the structure of your source data and has fewer built-in data modeling options. Data preparation is best done outside of Tableau (in ETL tools, Power Query, etc.).
Conclusion: Qlik offers more data modeling power. Tableau requires external preparation.
Visualizations and design options
Tableau has an enormous reputation for visual finesse. The graphs are aesthetic, responsive and customizable in detail. From story dashboards to interactive presentations, Tableau excels in visual communication.
Qlik Sense also offers beautiful visualizations, but with less freedom in layout. You work with predefined components. Functionality prevails over design. You can expand the design via extensions, but that requires extra setup.
Conclusion: Tableau is the best BI platform for visual storytelling. Qlik is more sober but functionally powerful.
Performance and scalability
Qlik Sense uses in-memory compression technology, so that it remains very fast even with large data sets. Your data is cached and processed efficiently, even with complex queries.
Tableau performs well, but can be less smooth with heavy or slow data sources, unless you work with extracts or Hyper files.
Conclusion: Qlik is better optimized for scale and speed. Tableau scores well, provided the configuration is correct.
Links and data sources
Both tools support a wide range of data sources: Excel, SQL, Google BigQuery, cloud storage, APIs, etc.
Tableau offers standard connectors and works well with live connections.
Qlik Sense also offers an extensive number of links, but is particularly notable for its ability to combine data from different sources within one model.
Conclusion: Both tools are versatile. Qlik is stronger in combining data sources; Tableau in live reporting.
Deployment: Cloud or On-Premise?
Tableau offers both an on-premise and cloud-based solution (Tableau Online). Management and publishing take place centrally.
Qlik Sense is available as Qlik Sense Enterprise (on-premise or cloud) and Qlik Sense SaaS. Both options offer complete control and scalability.
Conclusion: Both tools support hybrid environments. Qlik offers a little more hosting flexibility.
Costs and licensing model
Tableau uses a licensing model based on Viewer, Explorer and Creator licenses. This makes the pricing model transparent but sometimes costly for many users.
Qlik Sense works with user based or capacity based pricing, depending on the edition. In many cases, a little cheaper when rolling out on a large scale.
Conclusion: Tableau is easier to license, while Qlik is cheaper for large datasets and multiple users.
For which type of organization?
- Creative teams that design reports for stakeholders > Tableau
- Analytical teams looking for insights into complex data sets >Qlik Sense
- Organizations with limited data preparation external > Qlik Sense
- Companies with a focus on visual storytelling > Tableau
- Filtering sectors, root cause analysis > Qlik Sense
- Companies with a focus on visual presentations > Tableau
Summary and Conclusion
Both Qlik Sense and Tableau are top-notch BI tools. The choice between the two depends a lot on your business case:
- Do you want strong, visual dashboards for executive level or external customers? Then Tableau is the best choice.
- Looking for a tool to quickly and flexibly discover insights into raw data? Then Qlik Sense is a better fit for your organization.
Ideally, you should test both tools in a pilot environment with your own data and team. This is the only way to discover what works in your context.
Continue reading?
See how Power BI compares to the pre-configured InsightData apps on Qlik Sense.
Discover the key differences between Power BI and Qlik Sense in analytics power and flexibility.
Compare Power BI and Tableau in terms of visual dashboards and ease of use.
Learn when to switch from Excel to Power BI for more efficient reporting.
Compare Power BI to Looker in terms of cloud functionality, governance, and scalability.